Introduction
In today’s fast-paced world, contracts play a crucial role in every verbal or written transaction. For instance, when you buy milk from a store, your actions imply an agreement to purchase. This simple transaction is a form of contract. Legally, a contract is a formal, enforceable agreement between parties. Traditionally, contracts are written and signed by parties in the same location.
However, globalisation has given rise to E-contracts, which are now preferred for their convenience and efficiency. They are enforceable in the competent court of law. Parties to any contract are bound by the rights and duties mentioned in their contract. Generally, a contract is in the traditional pen-and-paper format, and the parties to such a contract are usually residing in the same city, place or locality.
Now, with the rise of globalisation, privatisation and liberalisation, business with foreign countries is booming like never before. How are such business agreements regulated? The answer is by E-contracts. E-contracts have become such a regular and important part of the legal world that parties prefer contracts to take place electronically rather than in person.
Table of Content 💻
What are E-Contracts?
E-Contracts or more commonly known as Electronic Contracts are contracts but in an electronic format. Then what are Contracts? According to Section 2(h) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a contract is an agreement enforceable by law. Hence, an E-Contract is any contract which is formatted in an electronic form.
They involve offer, acceptance, and consideration, just like traditional contracts. Despite the absence of physical meetings, E-contracts ensure a "meeting of the minds" or ‘consensus ad idem’. Although not specifically defined in the Indian Contract Act, E-contracts are recognized under Section 10A of the Information Technology Act, 2000, which validates contracts formed through electronic means.
In their entirety, E-contracts are digital. An E-contract can be said to mean any contract, that is legally binding, made through electronic means, by parties who are not necessarily in the same place at the same time. It means an electronic agreement that is legally enforceable by law. Even though there is an absence of a physical meeting of the parties, there is a consensus ad idem i.e meeting of the minds.
Types of E-Contracts
1. Click-Wrap Agreements:
These web-based contracts require users to accept terms by clicking “I accept” or “OK”. If users do not agree, they cannot use the service.
2. Shrink-Wrap Agreements:
These are software licensing agreements. The user agrees to the terms by opening the product’s packaging, which absolves the manufacturer of copyright infringement claims.
3. Browse-Wrap Agreements:
Binding contracts formed by the mere use of a website. Users must agree to terms and conditions to browse the site safely.
4. Smart Contracts:
Automatically enforced contracts built on blockchain technology. They minimise human error and reduce the need for intermediaries.
E-Contracts under Indian Law
While traditional Contracts are mainly governed by the Indian Contract Act, 1872, E-contracts on the other hand are governed by various laws, primarily the Information Technology Act, 2000 and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
The IT Act gives legal recognition to electronic signatures and records, while the Evidence Act outlines the admissibility of electronic evidence in court. The Consumer Protection Act, 2019, also safeguards consumers in e-commerce transactions.
Ground Reality of E-contracts
Editing and negotiating a contract virtually is a simpler method rather than having to meet in person. The Indian Contract Act solely deals with contracts in the traditional pen-and-paper mode and not with contracts conducted electronically. There are very few provisions relating specifically to electronic contracts. E-contracts are legally valid and enforceable in many parts of the world provided they fulfil the requirements of the statute in that area.
In India, if a contract, whether in the form of electronic or pen-paper, fulfils the conditions specified under Section 10 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 is deemed to be a valid agreement which in turn is an enforceable contract.
Not every person has access to a computer, a laptop or even an internet connection. Such people are forced to revert to their comfort zone i.e. a traditional pen and paper contract. Moreover, certain people who aren’t literate or who have no knowledge of the legalities of the world, resort to a third person who will help them in forming the contract they’re looking for.
A major challenge to the decline in popularity of E-contracts is illiteracy. It's as simple as this- People who are illiterate concerning the internet or the virtual world have no way of knowing how a contract functions virtually.
E-contracts have a wide range of applications in this world. Right from simple contracts like Sale to complex contracts like those of a CEO of a company. E-contracts are widely used in the fields of real estate, legal, healthcare, finance, and human resources. Legal formalities have become easier since the use of e-contracts as there is no strict requirement for parties to be in front of each other.
Now, the rule of communication in an E-contract has shifted to becoming instantaneous as previously, the rules were formulated keeping in mind the slow-paced nature of a traditional contract.
Validity and Challenges of E-Contracts
E-contracts face challenges related to the authenticity and reliability of electronic records. The Indian legal system addresses these issues through the IT Act and the Evidence Act. Electronic records are admissible as evidence, provided they meet certain conditions.
Courts have upheld the validity of E-contracts in several landmark cases, emphasising that they must fulfil the essential elements of traditional contracts. Another challenge is a smart contract. A smart contract is not legal in India because they aren’t readable by humans. Moreover, a third party who isn’t an intermediary, authenticates and records the transaction in a ledger.
Even though an E-contract is enforceable, there are still challenges posed to it. One of the main common issues that exists is determining the jurisdiction of the E-contract in Court. Such jurisdiction is currently determined with the help of the Information Technology Act, 2000.
Conclusion
E-contracts represent a significant advancement in the legal field, necessitating expertise from legal practitioners. Understanding the types and legal implications of E-contracts is crucial in navigating the challenges of the digital age. Both practitioners and courts must be adept at handling these contracts to ensure fair and just outcomes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: What is an E-contract?
A: An E-contract is a legally binding agreement made through electronic means, where parties do not need to be in the same location.
Q2: Are E-contracts legally recognized in India?
A: Yes, E-contracts are legally recognized under the Information Technology Act of 2000, which validates contracts formed electronically.
Q3: What are the types of E-contracts?
A: The main types are Click-Wrap Agreements, Shrink-Wrap Agreements, Browse-Wrap Agreements, and Smart Contracts.
Q4: How are E-contracts different from traditional contracts?
A: E-contracts are conducted electronically, and that’s the only point of difference between E-contracts and traditional contracts. E-contracts still require offer, acceptance, and consideration, similar to traditional contracts.
Q5: What laws govern E-contracts in India?
A: E-contracts are governed by the Information Technology Act, 2000, and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
Q6: Are electronic signatures valid in E-contracts?
A: Yes, electronic signatures are valid and recognized under the Information Technology Act, 2000.
Q7: What are the challenges faced by E-contracts?
A: Challenges include ensuring the authenticity, reliability, and admissibility of electronic records as evidence in court.
This Article is written by Tanaya Moholkar, a final year law student at Yashwantrao Chavan Law College, Pune.
Follow our legal journey on our social media and keep learning.
Helpful!